Invite a Co-worker
Send a co-worker an invite to the Exchange portal.Just enter their email address and we’ll connect them to register. After joining, they will belong to the same company.
Send Invite Cancel
80820members
346892posts

Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Solved
bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
9
4241

Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi,

 

Has anyone experience the following and know how to prevent it from occurring?

 

When re-ordering elements within a DDT Structure in the DDT Data Editor the comment of the element that is moved disappears. 

Attachments

Accepted Solutions
MarkPitout
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
0 Likes
3
2661

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

The response I got on this topic (case nr: 67577823):

 

This is scheduled to be correct in Control Expert V15.0

See Answer In Context

Tags (1)
9 Replies 9
MarkPitout
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
0 Likes
8
4228

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @bprobertson ,

 

My DDT editor does not behave the same as your's at all - when dragging elements of the DDT around, Control Expert actually makes copies of the elements. It does not reorder the elements.

However, those copies do not contain the comments of the element original elements.

 

See my video attached 

Attachments
bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
7
4186

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @MarkPitout,

 

Clicking and dragging items will duplicate items. 

Pressing shift before releasing the mouse button will instead move items.

MarkPitout
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
0 Likes
6
4145

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Okay. Did the shift-release thing - my Unity behaves the same as yours (comments are removed from the variable once moved).

 

I'll see if I can raise a ticket for this - given that this behavior isn't critical to how a PLC runs the code, I don't expect it will be high on the developers list of priorities. But let me raise it none the less. perhaps it will be sorted in a future hotfix or release

bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
0
4071

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @MarkPitout,

 

Correct it doesn't affect the behaviour of the PLC code however, from a development point of view it reduces productivity as you need to re-add comments if a change is made.

bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
4
3550

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @MarkPitout,

 

Did you end up getting a response from the ticket that you raised regarding this?

Tags (1)
MarkPitout
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
Schneider Alumni (Retired)
0 Likes
3
2662

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

The response I got on this topic (case nr: 67577823):

 

This is scheduled to be correct in Control Expert V15.0

Tags (1)
bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
0
2658

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi Mark,

 

Thanks for following up.

Tags (1)
bprobertson
Ensign
Ensign
0 Likes
1
1064

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @MarkPitout,

 

I've just tried this in Control Expert V15.0 SP1 and the issue has not been resolved.

Tags (1)
Mark_Pitout
Crewman
Crewman
0 Likes
0
1051

Re: Control Expert V14.1 DDT Data Editor

Hi @bprobertson,

 

Sadly you are correct - the bug is still there. I reproduced it myself in V15.0 this morning.

 

BTW I no longer work at Schneider Electric - I now work at a system integrator. But, one of my ex-colleagues at Schneider did contact me about this thread today - hopefully the software developers will look into it for the next hotfix or service pack.

Tags (1)